Rob Price
Gutbrain Records
rob + gutbrain.com = email


2026 November 18 • Wednesday

Nathaniel Benchley was the son of Robert and father of Peter and all three of them made considerable names for themselves in the literature world. Perhaps Nathaniel is the least famous.

I don't think I've read a whole Robert Benchley book although I have come across smaller samples of his work. As for Peter, I've read Jaws and that's it. And now I've read Nathaniel's first novel, Side Street.

It's a gentle and whimsical book, lightly humorous with some delicate gestures toward the dramatic. There's no plot to speak of, just a collection of vignettes with a Christmas party as a grand finale.

The story is simply about two families who end up living in adjoining brownstones in Manhattan.

The children play together in the shared back garden, the husbands drink together and the wives try to keep everything on track together.

The husbands are always coming up with terrible ideas for things to do, such as building a house in the backyard and then trying to install a swimming pool after that doesn't work out.

Even if the idea isn't necessarily a bad one, the execution is always botched.

At one point, as they discuss all the things that can make a picnic unpleasant, they try to arrange a horrible picnic on purpose, intentionally trying to run afoul of bad weather, forgotten items and any of the other common miseries that generally people hope to avoid.

These episodes stand on their own perfectly well and many of them were indeed previously published in magazines, as was common at the time. (The same thing is true of Catcher in the Rye.)

The dates of publication are 1948, 1949 and 1950, so the shadow of World War 2 occasionally falls upon some of the characters. Benchley touches very lightly on the traumas still experienced by the survivors and this delicate examination of psychological depth makes the general silliness slightly poignant.

I got my copy at Boston's Brattle Book Shop, one of my all-time favorite bookstores, and it's actually inscribed by Benchley himself:

It's a very satisfying slice of life comedy and drama woven softly together.

The first line is "As you turn east off Lexington Avenue in New York, north of Sixtieth Street, there is a street like a small valley, blocked at one end by the Third Avenue Elevated and with its north wall rising slowly until it reaches the heights of the apartment buildings the next block up".